Switch to ADA Accessible Website
Orlando Criminal Lawyer

Is a Guilty Plea Valid Even if the Prosecution Cannot Prove Its Case?

shutterstock_1014820045

Most criminal cases never go before a jury. Instead, the prosecution and defense negotiate a plea agreement. In exchange for the defendant’s agreement to plead guilty to a criminal charge, the prosecution agrees to a sentencing recommendation that is typically far less than the maximum penalty available under the law. Of course, any plea agreement is subject to the approval of the court.

And even when a defendant agrees to plead guilty, the prosecution is still required to present the judge with sufficient evidence to demonstrate there was a legitimate basis for the plea. In other words, the judge must understand that a jury could have “reasonably” found the defendant guilty based on the available evidence. This rule helps to ensure that an innocent defendant does not plead guilty by mistake–i.e., because they were misled into believing the prosecution had evidence that they did not.

Federal Appeals Court Throws Out Conviction of Truck Driver Over Fuel Dumping

It is also important that the prosecution demonstrate it can prove all of the actual elements of a charged crime. A recent decision from the U.S. 11th Circuit Court of Appeals, United States v. Coleman, provides a helpful illustration. In this case, the appellate court reversed a conviction based on a defendant’s guilty plea.

The alleged crime in this case is one that most people have never heard of–violating the Clean Water Act (CWA). Specifically, the CWA makes it a federal crime to dump certain pollutants into the “navigable waters” of the United States. The defendant here worked as a fuel truck driver. After loading the wrong type of fuel into his truck, he apparently decided to dump the incorrect fuel in a parking lot. Prosecutors alleged that the discarded fuel “migrated into adjacent storm water drainage that flows directly into a creek.” That creek connected to two other creeks, which ultimately led to the Ochlockonee River.

The Ochlockonee River was unquestionably a “navigable water” of the United States. But as the 11th Circuit explained, the “unnamed creek” where the defendant actually dumped his fuel was not. The “mere hydrologic connection” between the creek and the river was not enough to prove the “navigable waters” element of the CWA. Instead, the government was required to offer evidence showing this drainage ditch “had a significant chemical, physical, and biological impact” to the river in question.

More to the point, the Court said the defendant “would not have pled guilty” had he understood the government could not prove the drainage ditch was a navigable water. The 11th Circuit therefore vacated the guilty plea and conviction, and returned the case to a trial judge for further proceedings.

Contact Florida Criminal Defense Lawyer Jose Baez Today

Prosecutors are often quick to pressure defendants into accepting a plea deal. While a plea may represent the best outcome for your particular case, it is critical to never make such a decision without first retaining an experienced Orlando criminal defense attorney. Contact the Baez Law Firm today if you are facing criminal charges and need to speak with a lawyer right away.

 

Resource:

media.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/unpub/files/201915127.op2.pdf

https://www.baezlawfirm.com/when-can-police-initiate-a-stop-and-frisk-detention/

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
Miami

Miami Office

1200 Brickell Avenue #1410
Miami, FL 33131
Office: 305-999-5100
Fax: 305-999-5111
Orlando

Orlando Office

23 South Osceola Avenue
Orlando, FL 32801
Office: 407-705-2626
Fax: 407-705-2625

Email Us

Fields Marked * Are required

DISCLAIMER: Completing and submitting this form or otherwise merely contacting The Baez Law Firm or any individual at the firm will not establish an attorney/client relationship. Our firm cannot represent you until we determine that there would be no conflict of interest and that we are otherwise able to accept representation of your case. Please do not send any information or documents until a formal attorney/client relationship has been established through an interview with an attorney and you have been given authorization in the form of an engagement letter with The Baez Law Firm. Any information or documents sent via this form or otherwise prior to your receipt of an engagement letter will not be treated as confidences, secrets, or protected information of any nature. Submitting information regarding your potential case will not bar The Baez Law Firm from representing or continuing to represent a person or entity whose interest are adverse to your in condition with your case.

protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms
Please review the highlighted fields. They are required.
DISCLAIMER: This website contains information about The Baez Law Firm that includes testimonial statements from persons who are familiar with the firm's services. The testimonials shown are not necessarily representative of every person's experience with us. Testimonials from every client are not provided. As no two situations or persons are identical, the facts and circumstances of your situation may differ from those for which testimonials are shown. This website also includes information about some of the past results that we have obtained for our clients. Not all results are provided, and the results shown are not necessarily representative of all results obtained by us. No two situation are exactly alike; every person's situation is unique and the outcome for each person depends on the individual facts.

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.
MileMark Media - Practice Growth Solutions

© 2015 - 2021 Baez Law Firm. All rights reserved.
This law firm website and legal marketing are managed by MileMark Media.

Contact Form Tab Contact Form Tab